Active vs Passive: The Women in Our Torah Portions

It often feels challenging to me to talk about the women in our Torah portions because they are given short shrift and often portrayed as passive characters. Even in a portion entitled “The life of Sarah,” it is about her death and Abraham ‘s servant going to find a wife for Isaac. One of the more troubling motifs that appears 3 times in these chapters is a husband asking his wife to stand in as his sister. Abraham does this twice-with the famine leading to his descent into Egypt and when approaching Abimelech, the Philistine king. Isaac repeats his father’s behavior when he sees Abimelech in next week’s portion.

On the one hand, we can ask was this really a lie? In the story of Avimelech we learn that Avraham just didn’t tell the entire truth; after all Sarah was his half-sister.[1] They had the same father. Even if this was not the case, Jewish tradition would argue that a “white lie” can be said to preserve a person’s dignity,[2] all the more so to save a person’s life! Nevertheless, were Abraham and Isaac’s fear of being killed legitimate? Did they justify sacrificing their wives?

There is a rabbninic principle of מעשה לאבות סימן לבנים, that the actions of the fathers will be a sign for their children to emulate.[3] We never know what our children will learn from us and how it might manifest itself, directly or indirectly, in their lives. Isaac, who deceives Avimelech, stating that his wife, Rebecca, is his sister,[4] will in turn be deceived by his son Jacob with Rebecca’s help, who will in turn be deceived by eleven of his sons regarding Joseph. The cycle of deceipt has no end, from one generation to the next.

I wonder how Sarah and Rebecca felt about needing to play a role in this deception? Toward the end of this week’s portion we learn,” Isaac then brought her into the tent of his mother Sarah, and he took Rebekah as his wife. Isaac loved her and thus found comfort after his mother’s death.”[5] We hear nothing about how Rebecca feels about this occurring besides her uttering the words “I will go,”[6] and only after her father and brother offered her to Abraham’s servant.[7] The only actions she takes after offering Abraham’s servant and his camels water to drink are passive in nature, without speech.[8] , -the origin of our bedeken ceremony-are without speech. We only hear Rebecca’s voice after she struggles to bear children and then after she is pregnant and has children of her own. How can this be the case that in portions that center on women-the death of one and the marriage of another-that they remain passive beings throughout the narrative?

While this leaves a lot of room for modern Midrash, I hope we can conversely recognize when our relationship with another is I-It rather than the I-Thou of Martin Buber in which there is equal partnership. It is important for us to recognize not only what is said but also when there is silence in the text and how we might be able to fill in the gaps of some of that silence. This year I am studying with the Center of Contemporary Mussar, learning about middot[9] and utilizing them in accordance with Emmanuel Levinas’ first philosophy: our “infinite obligation or responsibility to serve the other.” Often we think of other as having a negative connotation-being “othered” as not belonging or being made to feel less than, leading to one’s silence. It is my hope that each of us can be more present to be there for the important “others” in our lives, considering their wants and needs, just as I wish our patriarchs had done for their wives. In so doing, may we break the cycle of מעשה לאבות סימן לבנים, our ignoring the other being a sign for our children to follow.


[1] Genesis 20:12

[2] See Babylonian Talmud Ketubot 16b-17a regarding Beit Hillel and Beit Shammai’s responses to a bride on her wedding night.

[3] See Ramban on Genesis 12:6

[4] They were cousins. Interestingly, it says Isaac was מצחק Rebecca, the same verb to describe Ishmael’s behavior, by which he was expelled.

[5] Genesis 24:67

[6] Genesis 24:58

[7] Genesis 24:51

[8] falling from a camel upon seeing Isaac and veiling herself

[9] Character attributes

The Small Kaf in Livkotah

One of the interesting things about the beginning of Haye Sarah is the small kaf in the word לבכתה, to cry on behalf of her passing.[1] Why is the kaf smaller? Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch suggests the small letter symbolizes that Abraham’s deepest grief was internal, intimate, and kept private within his home rather than being a public, theatrical display.[2] I don’t like this explanation because grief comes at different times to different people and one should not need to restrain one’s mourning to the private domain. A different explanation is that the kaf is small to emphasize לבתה, and her daughter. The Talmud teaches that Abraham and Sarah had a daughter named Bakol who died at the same time as Sarah. Therefore, Abraham mourned both Sarah and Bakol.[3]

Whatever the reason, this week’s portion is the first mention of eulogizing and burying the deceased. Abraham makes sure to acquire the gravesite with his own money and to ensure that Sarah has a proper burial. A lesson for us to take with that is the importance of taking care of our loved ones at the end of their lives. It is our responsibility and our privilege to engage in this final act of lovingkindness, as difficult as it is. At the same time, we must honor whatever it is we are feeling. Let us not feel that we need to minimize our crying in public but rather honor our emotions as they are during a time of great loss.


[1] Genesis 23:2

[2] Rabbi Samson Raphael Hirsch on Genesis 23:2 ד״ה ולבכתה

[3] Babylonian Talmud Bava Batra 16b

Words Matter: The Story of the Akeidah

Many a scholar has struggled with the concept of the Akeidah, the binding of Isaac. Rabbi Shalom Spiegel, who taught at the Jewish Theological Seminary, wrote a book entitled The Last Trial: On the Legends and Lore of the Command to Abraham to Offer Isaac as a Sacrifice. In that light I want to bring up the wording used at the beginning of the passage.

God tells Abraham “Go forth and take your son, your only son, that you loved, Isaac.”[1] A question asked by many commentators is why was Isaac’s name not said at the beginning? The medieval commentator Rashi cites a midrash from Genesis Rabbah asserting that Abraham stalled. When God said “your son,” he replied, “I have two sons: Isaac and Ishmael.” When God said your only son,” Abraham replied “This is the only son to his mother, and that is the only son to his mother.” God says “the one you love,” to which Abraham said, “I love both of them.” Finally God specifies Isaac. In this Midrash, Abraham argued for his sons, trying to stall the sacrifice, just as he had argued for the people of Sodom and Gemorah in Genesis 18.

The Midrash continues, though in a different vein. “Why did He not reveal the son’s name initially? So as not to confuse him abruptly, with the result of sending him of our his mind and driving him mad.”[2] The concept of tiruf daat that Rashi refers to is described by the commentator Aviva Zornberg as “an experience of sharp dislocation and discontinuity.”[3] Rather than have Abraham go through a brain shock, God according to Rashi has him ease into the idea of sacrificing his son.

The lesson I take from this is that words matter and that rabbinic teaching asserts that no word is extraneous. Your son, that you love, Isaac was not using extraneous words or words that were there for only poetics but rather words which took into account Abraham’s psychological state. Of course we can always overanalyze matters, which is dangerous. We cannot find an answer for everything and must be comfortable with ambiguity, which I will speak about tomorrow. At the same time, there is wonder and beauty in finding reasons for word order having been chosen in the Bible, especially when it is viewed from the perspective of the character’s psyche.


[1] Genesis 22:2

[2] Rashi on Genesis 22:2 citing Genesis Rabbah 55:7

[3] Aviva Zornberg “Lekh Lekha: Travails of Faith,” in Genesis: the Beginning of Desire. (Philadelphia: JPS, 1995), pg. 90.

Each of Us Has a Mission

It is now 16 years since I gave the Senior Sermon as a 5th Year rabbinical student at the Jewish Theological Seminary. In honor of that event, I want to share one piece of my sermon this evening.

On his comment on the first verse “Go forth for yourself,” Rabbi Sholom Noach Berezovsky in his book Netivot Shalom comments “no person is like another” — from the moment of Adam’s creation, each person has their own destiny and role, and no one can fix what is the responsibility of another. In other words, each of us has our own, personal mission to fulfill in the world.

This text has brought me great comfort over the years, especially when I feel that I am in the midst of doldrum or stagnation. Remembering that we each are unique and have our own personal mission in this world often brings me energy. It reminds me of Pirkei Avot, the Ethics of the Fathers, that each of us must do our own portion of the work.

The next time you feel monotony or you are stuck, I hope you will reflect on this teaching of Rabbi Berezovsky and that it will help jumpstart you in life’s challenging moments.